Political CHIPS

Political CHIPS - Conservative Heritage Institute for Principled Strength

Dream Act students sue to stop Senate filibuster

By Stephen Dinan

-

The Washington Times

Illegal immigrant students and members of the House sued the Senate this week to try to overturn the upper chamber’s filibuster rule, arguing that the 60-vote supermajority requirement violates the Constitution and is blocking important legislation such as legalization for illegal immigrants.

If successful, the lawsuit, filed Monday, would rewrite the way the Senate operates — though courts generally have been reluctant to meddle in internal congressional rules.

Still, the effort mixes two thorny issues in separation of powers an immigration, and is likely to keep the Dream Act at the forefront of  the national debate. The bill would legalize illegal immigrant students and  young adults who were brought to the U.S. as children and who are seen as among the toughest cases in the immigration debate.

In late 2010,  the Dream Act passed the House but was blocked from action by a filibuster in the Senate. The 55-41 vote fell five shy of the 60  needed  to overcome a filibuster.

“The  filibuster is exactly that — it’s a rule that’s crippled our system  of government. Undocumented youth,  perhaps like no other  group, understands about the legislative  process,” said Caesar  Vargas, an illegal immigrant who went through  college and law school  and could benefit from the Dream Act  legalization bill. “We have  lived it; we have shed tears for it. And we have seen a minority able to cripple dreams.”

The filibuster is not found in the Constitution, but rather is a Senate rule that stems from its tradition of extended debate.   Lawmakers used to  use that  extended debate privilege to talk legislation to death, so the chamber came up with the “cloture” rule, which, after several changes,  now allows debate to be cut off if 60 of the 100 senators vote to do so.

Use of filibusters has grown dramatically in recent years as the minority party has turned to it repeatedly — so much so that every piece of legislation is now  assumed to need 60 votes to succeed.

Three Dream Act-eligible  students are suing, along with four Democratic members of the House  and Common Cause, a group that pushes for campaign finance restrictions.

Their suit names Vice President Joseph R.  Biden  Jr., who is president ofthe Senate, and three top officers of  the  chamber: the secretary of the  Senate, the parliamentarian and the sergeant-at-arms.

The members of Congress said the Senate filibuster rule hurts them by diluting the power of their vote.

“It invalidates my vote for significant legislation favored by the majority,” said Rep. Henry C. “Hank” Johnson Jr., a Georgia Democrat who is part of the lawsuit. “This is not right and it is definitely not fair. The filibuster is no longer useful, and it needs to go.”

Courts generally have deferred to the chambers of Congress to set their own rules, and it’s not clear that the federal judiciary would want to intervene in this case either — though no challenge to the   filibuster   has reached  the Supreme Court.

“The history of this kind of  litigation is the courts have stayed away from the merits of the  filibuster. They tend  to find just on different grounds reasons not  to consider the merits,”  said Michael  J. Gerhardt,  director of the Center for Law and Government at the University of North Carolina School of Law.

The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

Asked about  the likelihood of courts taking the  case, Emmet Bondurant, the lead attorney in the case, pointed to  Supreme Court decisions overturning  the line-item veto and about how  Congress chooses to seat  its members  as evidence the court will rule  on   internal congressional  matters.

Common  Cause is leading the lawsuit. The group used to strongly  support the filibuste rule but said it has changed its stance after a long review of the history of the practice.

“Quite simply, we were wrong then, and we are convinced we are right now,” said Bob Edgar, president and CEO of Common Cause.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/may/15/dream-act-students-...

Views: 14

Tags: Act, DREAM, Senate, illegal, immigration

Comment

You need to be a member of Political CHIPS to add comments!

Join Political CHIPS

Comment by Kathy Brown, Esq. on May 17, 2012 at 10:46pm

I hope these people are aware that, as [admitted] illegals, these plaintiffs have no standing whatever, to petition our courts for ANYTHING.  Much less do they have standing to petition the courts to change internal Senate rules.

What a farce this is!  This case should be immediately dismissed, due to plaintiffs' lack of standing. 

However:  Since this is about illegals, doubtless some lily-livered Judge will nurse it along for awhile.  Better yet, what am I thinking?  Perhaps the DOJ will weigh in, and just PRESTO CHANGE-O!  Invent standing for these illegals! 

If the DOJ can dismiss the case against the New Black Panthers after they were found guilty of voter intimidation, hey, it ought to be an easy thing to grant standing to a bunch of illegals.  After all:  It is an election year, and law be d_ _ _ _d!

Thank you for your support!

Latest Activity

Political Chips's event was featured
Thumbnail

Celebration of Liberty Event at Jayhawk Room

June 8, 2013 from 6pm to 9pm
The Kansas Sovereignty Coalition and the Kansas State Rifle Association’s Celebration of Liberty…See More
4 hours ago
Political Chips posted an event

Celebration of Liberty Event at Jayhawk Room

June 8, 2013 from 6pm to 9pm
The Kansas Sovereignty Coalition and the Kansas State Rifle Association’s Celebration of Liberty…See More
4 hours ago
Profile IconPolitical CHIPS - Conservative Heritage Institute for Principled Strength via Facebook
Facebook7 hours ago · Reply
Angelo H Mino commented on Angelo H Mino's video
Thumbnail

Please Play Taps For Me

"I never made it. I tried, we all did.Oh, that ugly face of warI hope you never see.I felt a higher…"
8 hours ago
Angelo H Mino commented on Angelo H Mino's blog post The Wrong Way to Reform Immigration
"Sister Mary! Well done and said! I have a very simplistic solution: Let's build a better fence…"
9 hours ago
Angelo H Mino posted a video

Please Play Taps For Me

Jerry Plantz's visual patriotic poem.
9 hours ago
Mary C. Weaver commented on Angelo H Mino's blog post The Wrong Way to Reform Immigration
"Mr. Mino you've written a superb comment on this thorny problem.  As a 2nd generation…"
11 hours ago
Mary C. Weaver liked Political Chips's video
11 hours ago
Profile IconPoliticalCHIPS via Twitter
Meet Chipper Jones! Learn everything you need to know about politics in five minutes or less! http://t.co/C8YdouURCP
Twitter15 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Randy Due posted discussions
16 hours ago
David posted blog posts
16 hours ago
DAVID J. POWELL posted a blog post
16 hours ago
Political Chips shared their blog post on Facebook
17 hours ago
Loretta Rebeck commented on Political Chips's blog post Breaking: While all eyes were on Oklahoma…Senators approve amnesty bill
"I agree with W. Dale Russell.  Instead of spending money on 'Infrastructure', we…"
17 hours ago
Leslie Schmidt posted a blog post

Don’t mess with Xmas: Texas passes “Merry Christmas” bill

The Huffington PostPosted: May 22, 2013 10:11 pm …See More
17 hours ago
David and W Dale Russell are now friends
yesterday
Profile IconPoliticalCHIPS via Twitter
Meet Chipper Jones! Learn everything you need to learn about politics in 5 minutes or less! http://t.co/hSy9FDJ8tr
Twitteryesterday · Reply · Retweet
Delbert Bryant shared Political Chips's blog post on Facebook
yesterday
Profile IconPoliticalCHIPS via Twitter
Do you really want the IRS enforcing your healthcare? http://t.co/zmipSLoVKE
Twitteryesterday · Reply · Retweet
Angelo H Mino posted a photo

Bill S744 The best promotion ever!

844 pages, this is the result!
yesterday

Sponsored Ads



Members

Badge

Loading…

© 2013   Created by Political Chips.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service